Find a Birth Father: Paternity Test v. DNA Test

Sunny Morton

Share with a friend: 

When trying to find a birth father, you should know the difference between a paternity test and a DNA test like AncestryDNA or 23andMe. Here’s what you need to know if you’re asking, “Who’s my biological father?”

When searching for a birth father, you want to use all available tools at hand. This includes DNA testing. But what’s the difference between a paternity test and a consumer DNA test for family history, like from 23andMe, AncestryDNA, MyHeritage, etc)? They are different tests, and you may choose to pursue one over another, depending on your situation.

This article doesn’t constitute legal advice. It’s just meant to give you some general background.

How Does a Paternity Test Identify a Birth Father?

A paternity test is a one-to-one comparison of the DNA of a person with the DNA of a potential father. Its purpose is to ask, “Is this the biological father of that person?”

To take a paternity test, you have to have a presumed father who is alive and willing to test (which, depending on your circumstances, may be ordered by a court).

A paternity test can EXCLUDE a man as a biological father with 99.9% accuracy if it determines that the two people don’t share enough DNA to be that closely related. Is the reverse true, also? Almost, but not precisely. According to paternity test provider Affinity DNA, “When the probability of paternity is 99.99%, this means that the man who has been tested is 99.99% more likely than a random man [from the same ethnic group] to be the biological father of the child.” (1)

Because of increased possibilities for error or fraud with at-home paternity tests, some situations call for a legal, witnessed DNA test. Even with these, there’s a slim chance that a man who isn’t the birth father (but who is closely related to him) may be falsely identified by a paternity test. (Read more about that here.)

If the alleged father is alive and willing to test, it’s best to start with a paternity test. But if he’s not—OR if you take the test with the presumed father and it’s negative—OR if you have no idea who the father may be—then it may be time to turn to consumer DNA testing.

Consumer DNA Testing to Find a Birth Father

Consumer DNA testing for family history gives you a one-to-many comparison. A person taking a test from AncestryDNA, MyHeritage, 23andMe or other testing companies will receive a list of people who share enough DNA with them that they are likely to be biologically related. Each testing company offers different tools to help you determine HOW you might be related to each of your DNA matches.

If a person’s birth father has tested with the same company, he will show up at the top of a person’s list of matches with a relationship estimate of “father.” (It’s rare but possible, like with paternity testing, that another man who is related but is not the biological father, may show up in this position.)

Most people who are searching for a birth father (especially outside the United States) will NOT necessarily find that he has tested. BUT relatives of a birth father may appear in the match list. This is why, if one-on-one paternity testing isn’t an option for you, consumer DNA testing gives you another option. With additional research, you may be able to identify the birth father’s extended family and perhaps eventually the man himself.

If you’ve already taken a consumer DNA test, how likely is it that you’ll be able to identify a birth parent or sibling now? Our free guide to using DNA for birth roots has a handy table that gives you a good idea, based on how close your current matches are.

Get our free birth roots guide

As more people take DNA tests over time, your list of DNA matches will grow, and so will the possibility of identifying a birth father, or at least learning more about his extended family. It does take some skill to analyze your DNA match list, and that’s where we come in. What can we help you with next?

Get More DNA Inspiration

Our free monthly newsletter delivers more great articles right to you.

4 Comments

  1. Mia Jones

    I don’t understand why my daughter who has been tested with ancestry dna has someone show up as her uncle who I’ve never met however his brother is someone I knew because I dated his roommate. I know who I slept with 1 year later and who the father is. It was a one night stand. She doesn’t believe me and I think I need to see if this man will have a paternity test to prove to her who her biological father is. I just don’t understand how the other person who is deceased family showed up on her profile or whatever????

    Reply
    • Diahan Southard

      It is clear that DNA is showing a connection to this man. And an uncle relationship is very close, and there are not very many other relationships she could have to him. Certainly having someone from the family of the man you believe is her father take a DNA test could help you both see if there is a genetic relationship between them.

      Reply
  2. Farrah Ezell

    I have taken a DNA test with Ancestry but I still have not found any clues to who my biological father is. I do have biological relatives show up, but honestly known very closely related. I dint know what to do. I would give almost anything to find family.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Send this to a friend